81 years after Nuremberg: International Justice in a World of Sovereign States
by Natalia Modla

United States Army Signal Corps photographer, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
With Nazi Germany defeated in May 1945, the Allies faced a question that would shape the future of international criminal law: how should those responsible for its atrocities be brought to
justice? The Allied powers had no disagreements on the fact that the Nazi leaders should be punished. While Britain and the Soviet Union were initially in favour of executions, the US government advocated for a different mechanism: an international trial. They proposed a specialised international court, comprising judges from the four major Allied powers, to determine the grounds for Nazi leaders' punishment under international law, with the ability to impose sentences ranging from imprisonment to execution by hanging. For the first time in modern international criminal justice, senior political and military leaders would face prosecution before an international tribunal for crimes committed via the state. On 21 November 1945, US chief prosecutor Robert H. Jackson delivered the opening for these trials: “Never before in legal history has an effort been made to bring within the scope of a single litigation the developments of a decade, covering a whole continent, and involving a score of nations, countless individuals, and innumerable events.”
While international conventions had already prohibited certain wartime conduct, the Nuremberg Charter, which established the IMT, identified four categories of crimes: crimes against peace, war crimes, crimes against humanity and conspiracy to commit. Two of the charges brought up, crimes against peace and crimes against humanity, were innovative as they had never before
been prosecuted as formal distinct crimes under international law.
Building upon the IMT's judgment, the United Nations General Assembly adopted Resolution 95(I) in December 1946, affirming the principles of international law recognised in the Nuremberg Charter and the Tribunal's judgment. The resolution also prioritised plans to formulate these principles as part of a broader codification of offences against “the peace and security of mankind.” This laid the groundwork for major developments in international criminal law, as these principles would later influence the Rome Statute and the establishment of theInternational Criminal Court (ICC).
Today, the ICC is one of the principal international institutions responsible for prosecuting individuals accused of war crimes and crimes against humanity. While states that have ratified
the Rome Statute are legally obliged to cooperate with the ICC, a clear tension remains between the law and its enforceability. Kenneth Waltz's neorealism offers an explanation, as it argues that international relations are characterised by anarchy, or the absence of a central authority above sovereign states. For example, in April 2025, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu visited Hungary at the invitation of Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán. Despite an outstanding ICC arrest warrant and Hungary's legal obligation to cooperate with the Court, the Hungarian authorities did not arrest him. This illustrates neorealism, as states may prioritise their own political interests over international obligations. Unlike domestic courts, which operate within state boundaries and have forces such as the police, the ICC has no independent enforcement capacity to carry out its orders. Instead, it relies on state cooperation. This creates an opportunity for states to selectively enforce their obligations, effectively allowing them to "cherry-pick" which arrest warrants they comply with. They may cooperate in one case, but political considerations may discourage them from doing so in another. Thus, although international criminal law establishes legally binding obligations, the realities of international relations can significantly limit their enforcement.
Bibliography
encyclopedia.ushmm.org. (n.d.). International Military Tribunal. [online] Available at: https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/timeline-event/holocaust/1942-1945/international-military-tribunal
[Accessed 20 Nov. 2026].
Finding under article 87(7) of the Statute on Hungary’s non-compliance with the Court’s request to
cooperate in the provisional arrest of Benjamin Netanyahu and referral to the Assembly of States Parties
[2025] ICC-01/18–462 (International Criminal Court).
Holocaust Encyclopedia. (2020). How were the crimes defined? | Holocaust encyclopedia. [online] Available at: https://encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/how-were-the-crimes-defined [Accessed20 Nov. 2026].
Jackson, R. (1945). Opening Statement before the International Military Tribunal - Robert H Jackson Center. [online] Roberthjackson.org. Available at: https://www.roberthjackson.org/speech-and-writing/opening-statement-before-the-international-military-tribunal/ [Accessed 20 Nov. 2026].
Redraft of Charter, Submitted by British Delegation. (1945). International Conference on Military Trials.London.
The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica (2018). Nürnberg trials | facts, definition, & prominent defendants. In: Encyclopedia Britannica. [online] Available at: https://www.britannica.com/event/Nurnberg-trials [Accessed 20 Nov. 2026].
Waltz, K. (1979). Theory of International Politics. Addison-Wesley Publishing Company.





Comments