top of page

Can the NHS Rely on Private Healthcare? The Legal and Commercial Challenges

13 hours ago
3 min read

By Tara Boucher

I’m sure many of us have experienced going to book an appointment with the NHS, and being told we have to wait months for an appointment. These long waiting times are a significant challenge in the NHS, with 6.24 million patients waiting for treatments to be carried out across England. COVID-19 had a significant impact on NHS capacity, and created a ‘growing backlog of care’ in England. To address this, the NHS has started to increasingly collaborate with independent healthcare providers. Between September 2024 and August 2025, 6.15 million appointments, tests, and operations were delivered by independent providers for NHS patients. Today, 10% of NHS funded elective (planned) care is provided by independent healthcare providers. 


One example of how successful these collaborations can be is the collaboration between the University Hospitals Plymouth NHS Trust (UHP) and the independent healthcare provider Healthcare Business Solutions UK (HBSUK). UHP is one of the largest hospitals in the NHS South West region, however, it was struggling with workforce capacity, long waiting lists, and long patient wait times. According to HBSUK, this collaboration was extremely successful, with an 83% reduction in waiting times, over 18,000 patients served, and 75% of patients receiving a same day discharge. Dr. Gemma Crossingham, a Consultant Anaesthetist, stated that the partnership achieved ‘a working model with levels of efficiency and productivity that we could never have achieved without their (HBSUK’s) help’. 


With success stories like these, why isn’t the NHS expanding these partnerships to address further issues? While these collaborations have clear benefits, expanding them raises legal and commercial challenges. If the NHS was to expand these partnerships, they would need to ensure that independent providers are selected fairly and that NHS funding is used effectively. The rules that NHS organisations must follow when selecting healthcare providers are set out in the Provider Selection Regime (PSR). While the PSR does provide more flexibility in how external healthcare providers are selected, NHS organisations must still comply with its requirements when entering into or modifying contracts with independent providers. For example, if an NHS hospital has partnered with an independent provider to reduce waitlist times, and wants to expand this partnership to treat more patients, it must consider whether a new provider selection process is required. This might delay the expansion of these successful partnerships, which could prevent NHS organisations from increasing their capacity as quickly as they would like.


Furthermore, under the PSR, NHS organisations must consider whether these partnerships will deliver value for money. The fundamental difference between the NHS and independent healthcare providers is that many independent providers operate for a profit, whereas the NHS is publicly funded through taxes. Expanding these partnerships could place additional financial pressure on the NHS, and may raise the question of whether paying independent providers to support with additional operations offers sufficient benefits relative to the costs. If this is not the case, the arrangement may not be sustainable.


Overall, collaborations between the NHS and independent healthcare providers can significantly help with reducing waiting times and increasing capacity. Examples such as UHP and HBSUK’s show the benefits that these collaborations can offer, such as increasing efficiency and capacity. The next step would be to expand these partnerships, however, this process is not straightforward. The legal framework plays an important role in ensuring that NHS funding is used effectively and that patients continue to receive the highest quality care possible. While independent providers can offer a valuable solution to the challenges faced by the NHS, they should not be seen as a replacement for long term investment in the NHS.


Sources


 
 
 

Comments


© 2025 by UCL LAW FOR ALL SOCIETY 

bottom of page