Big Law v. Big Tech: Beyond the Automation of Legal Services
By Freddie Grimshaw

Artificial Intelligence. It’s practically every news story in every sector for the last few years, but an interesting story is rising in the world of legal services. No, this is not about the death of the billable hour model, nor even the replacement of lawyers with AI. Instead, are the juggernauts of the legal world slowly evolving into AI firms?
This May, Kirkland & Ellis announced it had set aside $500mn to develop its own AI model, with Jon Ballis, its chair, telling the FT that this new technology would allow Kirkland’s current ‘collective intelligence’ to spread throughout the firm.
But why?
AI has caused significant problems for law firms since the launch of Chat GPT. Sullivan & Cromwell, to name just one, announced its filings to a US federal bankruptcy court contained several AI “Hallucinations.” Furthermore, almost every lawyer you speak to isn’t totally convinced of the promises these AI labs are making. This isn’t exclusive to the US giants, in October leaked emails from Freshfields described plans for an AI lab that could be ‘worth billions,’ aiming to sell the new tools to rivals, coming just after the signing a new deal with Anthropic. So why would Kirkland throw half a billion dollars at developing its own AI system when Harvey and Legora are already existing systems specialised for legal work?
It is evident that Big Law wants to develop its own AI tools to solve two major problems. Firstly, enhancing client confidence in the technology through cutting out third party servers and systems, thus ensuring the security of sensitive data. However, if a potential roll out is too quick it could be seriously inhibited by existing ‘No-AI’ client lists, a major bottleneck issue in the sector. Secondly, firms inherently seek to become more profitable. In both getting in on the AI arms race and increasing efficiency through scaling AI use on alongside rising client confidence, law firms would in theory increase their already eye-watering revenues.
Remarkably, Big Law is very well equipped to develop these tools. First, unlike AI labs, Law firms have their own specialised legal minds: lawyers (of all levels). While not computer programmers, lawyers know what they want from these AI systems, which can prove invaluable in allowing these firms to create a system that is far better tailored to lawyer’s needs, compared to those provided by tech companies. This is already being utilised with many top lawyers dedicating time to train these models, allowing for far quicker and more direct feedback. This avoids the practical limitations faced by many AI labs looking to develop similar legal tools. Furthermore, Big Law is also backed by its own vast investment capabilities. With Kirkland’s $500mn, legal giants are far from lacking the required capital needed to structure and grow their own AI labs.
However, there are several risks involved in Big Law’s expansion into AI. Already we have seen, Wall Street and other institutions are pressuring law firms to cut fees, given that AI helps lawyers work quicker and cheaper. In adopting its own AI tools, even more specialised than current models, law firms could again see mounting pressure to cut their fees. This would result in reduced revenues, despite firms being more efficient. Moreover, this growing rivalry with finance could also expand into the realm of employment, with both sectors in an ongoing talent acquisition war, a plunge in law firms’ revenues could prevent salaries in the industry from growing, thus losing out on talented future lawyers to finance. Finally, with many AI labs going public, their need to lock down Big Law as long term clients is vital; if unable to secure these income streams AI labs could face serious risks to investor confidence, at worst being a contributing factor to the bursting of the AI bubble.
It is unlikely that the premier law firms outright become AI companies. However, in a more probable outcome over the next few years, AI labs and law firms will increasingly work together to create an ever more specialising software for legal work, putting both their strengths on the issue together.
Sources:
Kirkland spends 500m on AI infrastructure
Hallucination of Cases in Legal briefs
Freshfields leaked plans for AI
Why law firms should resist AI spin-off
Expansion of Legora (AI law firm)
TLDR news





Comments