top of page

A Fairer End to Relationships: Accounting for Needs in Cohabitant Relationship Breakdown

By Maria Dzhioeva


Nearly two decades on from the Law Commission’s Report “Cohabitation: The Financial Consequences of Relationship Breakdown (2007)” proposing a statutory scheme on cohabitation and the subsequent Parliamentary calls for development, the Government’s June 2026 consultation, “A Fairer End to Relationships: A Consultation on Reforming Financial Remedies on Divorce and Strengthening Protections for Cohabitants at the End of Their Relationship," brings a tentative statutory framework of

automatic financial protection to qualifying cohabitants. The proposal attempts to formalise a coherent framework, attending to questions of fairness, autonomy, and protection, which characteristically problematise cohabitation’s legal stature.


An adequate correlation between the normative demands of cohabitant relationships and existing legal avenues for protection has been evidently lacking since Burns v Burns [1984], wherein the limitations of the legal framework in accounting for the domestic contributions of the primary caregiving parent struggled to translate into equivalent financial entitlement upon separation. Where marriage provides a supportive statutory framework for financial provision and security to spouses upon separation or bereavement, that protection does not currently extend in relative measure to their unmarried counterparts, not infrequently shouldering corresponding responsibility. With 3.5 million couples in the UK now living together without entering marital or civil partnership relations, and projections suggesting that one in four families will be unmarried cohabiting units by 2031, reforms in legal regulation are welcome to bridge the gap in legal and social realities of many couples.


In the absence of an equivalent to the financial remedies available on divorce, existing legal precedent pertaining to cohabitant claims has historically relied on, but not been limited to, an application of property law, trusts and beneficial ownership, contracts, and any relevant available avenues through litigation, with varying success. The existing avenues therefore offer comparatively fragmented and thus limited scope for compensation and legal recourse is found wanting.


A Fairer End to Relationships, in proposing a more holistic account for the economic realities of cohabitant relationships, nevertheless re-affirms the distinction between cohabiting couples and their married counterparts. Cohabitants may not be entitled to share in the assets or wealth accrued by their partner during the course of the relationship. As opposed to broader principles governing the three-step divorce procedure, including the sharing principle, the proposed financial provision for cohabitants places emphasis on the introduction of the needs-based framework - a reform which has quickly attracted growing scrutiny.


The distinction between needs and discretionary needs in the proposal raises difficulties at two levels. Interfamilially, the distinction of needs and discretionary needs risks misinterpreting the challenge of constituting luxury between households at different socioeconomic stages: what constitutes a luxury for one household may not for another; alternatively, ordinary expenses for one household may be considered luxury purchases for another. The development of the proposal is therefore expected to develop the distinction in order to hopefully give a fair account of financial remedy upon the event of household breakdown, and avoid trading sensitivity to individual circumstances for a consistent yet rigid codified framework.


Intrafamilially, the distinction raises questions regarding the assessment of wealth allocation, specifically the difficulty of quantifying the economic contributions of unpaid domestic labour - a vulnerability which continues to predominantly concern female partners in committed heterosexual relationships. The process of comparing or reconciling earning capacities of two partners engenders a complex assessment of one partner’s financial needs against the assets accumulated by the other, especially where the financial resources in their own name have been made possible by the caregiving of the partner rendered financially weaker upon separation. The law should not leave someone financially vulnerable simply because they did not marry, particularly where the material reality of unmarried cohabitant couples may reflect marital responsibility, or when decision to marry remains contingent on a range of complications spanning financial need, party disagreement, or simply delayed marriage status.


This poses potential questions as to the extent of protection available to vulnerable parties in the absence of judicial discretion. Existing legal precedent has made clear that factual and functional characteristics of cohabitant relationships are capable of blurring traditional distinctions based on marital status. The invocation of human-rights principles in an examination of the practical realities of the surviving cohabitant in Re McLaughlin has previously illustrated the potential of functional considerations in challenging the exclusive status of privileges reserved for married couples. The UK Supreme Court held that the exclusion of the parent from the benefits of the Widowed Parent’s Allowance came into friction with Article 14, read with Article 8, of the European Convention on Human Rights. The practical realities of family life can carry considerable weight in the conversation regarding forms-based familial distinctions. Importantly, the decision in Re McLaughlin hinged on an adequate consideration of the interests of the dependent children in the wake of parental separation, no matter the marital status or form of family unit.


This priority in the legislation of cohabitant relationships evidently prevails in A Fairer End to Relationships, which stresses the emphasis on the protection of children's financial welfare. Whilst the opt-out clauses present some avenue of autonomous legal recourse, the proposal affirms that the opt-out claims may not overrule financial claims for the benefit of children, arising under the Child Support Act 1991 and Schedule 1 of the Children Act 1989.


Nevertheless, the proposed reforms extend beyond the child-focused reasoning in Re McLaughlin, providing a promising and overdue address to the various gaps between functional and legal realities faced by informal relationships upon dissolution. Still, the proposition of the needs-based model calls for a developed account in questions of unpaid domestic contributions and individual circumstances. The framework calls back into question the debate of form versus function in the pursuit of an adequate theoretical conceptual basis for the legal recognition of informal adult relationships.


Overall, A Fairer End to Relationships represents an important and long-anticipated reform in legal protection for cohabiting couples. Its effectiveness ultimately rests on further clarification to reconcile competing interests, with regard to protecting individual autonomy, recognising economic dependency, and maintaining judicial flexibility – elements that remain pertinent given the highly individual and sensitive nature central in family law.


Sources:

1. Ali, Sarfraz, and Michael Gouriet.

“ A Fairer End to Relationships: Cohabitation on Separation.”

Withers LLP, 15 Sept. 2026, https://www.withersworldwide.com/en-gb.

2. Douglas, Gillian, et al. “Cohabitants, property and the law: A study of injustice.” The Modern Law Review, vol. 72, no. 1, 29 Dec. 2008, pp. 24–47, https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1468-2230.2009.00732.x.

3. Griffiths, Kathy. From Form to Function and Back Again: A New Conceptual Basis for Developing Frameworks for the Legal Recognition of Adult Relationships -Orca,

4. Ministry of Justice. “ A Fairer End to Relationships: A Consultation on Reforming Financial Remedies on Divorce and Strengthening Protections for Cohabitants at the End of Their Relationship”. CP 1581, June 2026,

5. Rodway, Helen. “ A human rights framing of cohabitation reform.” Legal Studies, vol. 46, no. 3, 4 June 2026, pp. 353–371, https://doi.org/10.1017/lst.2026.10131.

 
 
 

Comments


© 2025 by UCL LAW FOR ALL SOCIETY 

bottom of page