top of page

Brazil’s Runoff Dispute and the Issue of Ineligibility: The Brazil 2026 Election

By Lauren Nichols

On October 25th, Brazil’s president Lula Inácio Lula da Silva won the election with 51.79% of votes against 48.21% Flávio Bolsonaro, taking a fourth term in office. However, Bolsonaro did not concede and has refused to recognize the result, calling for annulment. As of right now, reports differ on what he will do next. This issue is a useful case on how law handles a contested vote, as-well as what and who decides upon candidates being barred from office. In this instance, the Supreme Federal Court (STF) and Superior Electoral Court (TSE) have to decide just how much room elected lawmakers have to change the rules that judges enforce.

 

Shortly after polls were closed, the STF Justice Cristiano Zanin ordered all polling to stay open until 7pm, responding to claims from Jair Bolsonaro that heavy rain in areas of the south and São Paulo prevented voter turnout, and from Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva that a lack of buses in Bahia and São Paulo prevented voters from reaching the poll. While requests to extend voting hours are typically decided by the STF Bolsonaro’s allies claimed this individual order bypassed standard protocols, pointing to a potential conflict of interest since Zanin served as Lula’s personal criminal defense lawyer before Lula appointed him to the STF in 2023. Despite this, the STF president Kassio Nunes Marques, who had been appointed by Bolsonaro, said the extension affected the vote count process, but

not the result.

 

To annul a result, it must be assumed that an irregularity could have changed the outcome. While the STF counted about 34,400 votes after 5pm, the election had a 4.4 million vote margin. Despite this, Bolsonaro says he plans to request an annulment; however, it is unclear how this would be done legally. This situation brings up the topic of ineligibility, which bars someone from standing from office without stripping their right to vote. In 2023, five STF judges barred Jair Bolsonaro from office until 2030 for abusing his power and for unevidenced claims towards the voting system. This ban was based off the Ficha Limpa (“Clean Record”) law of 2010, which disqualifies candidates from running for eight years after a panel conviction, a removal from office, or a resignation used to escape impeachment. The Ficha Limpa has always been contested, as a shown by Keith Rosenn’s account. The STF spilt five-to-five on applying it to the 2010 elections; however, an internal rule dictating that a tie upholds a law's constitutionality ultimately resulted in a ruling in favor of the law. Later in December, Rosenn states that a single STF minister overrode a TSE case by issuing a preliminary injunction when Natan Donadon had been re-elected. This was despite two convictions in state courts, and it allowed Donadon to retake his seat in congress whilst the STF needed to go over its own ruling. The minister had relied on the presumption of innocence as the TSE had refused to register Donadon’s re-election under Ficha Limpa. This account shows how the courts proportionality and composition can change

how the Ficha Limpa is used. In 2025, Congress reformed the Ficha Limpa law to be softer, altering the law so that the 8-year ban begins from the date of jail time or initial court conviction rather than after the convict’s full sentence. However, the STF review was stalled as Minister Mendes established a transition period of 18 months.

 

Hence, a question arises: can the loser of an election can legally overturn the outcome by calling it unfair? In the case of Brazil in 2026, it looks unlikely, as the margin of the votes is simply too large. However, the decision as to which candidates are considered ineligible still remains at large. Although the courts apply the rules, it is congress who writes them, and congress also who seems to be moving to loosen them. This case reflects a deep debate where supporters advocate for strict rules to limit electoral abuse, while critics argue that because all judges and politicians possess inherent interests, power must be balanced between both branches. Only further ruling and Bolsonaro’s next actions will see how the Ficha Limpa is applied.

 

Sources

Wells, I. and Khalil, H. (2026). Brazil election: Lula wins fourth term in dramatic comeback over Bolsonaro. BBC News. [online] 26 Oct. Available at:


Savarese, M. and Jeantet, D. (2023). Former Brazilian president Jair Bolsonaro barred from running for office until 2030. [online] NBC4 Washington. Available at: https://www.nbcdfw.com/news/national-international/brazils-jair-bolsonaro-is-barred-from-running-for-office-for-8-years/3287871/ [Accessed 2 Nov. 2026].


Redaktion blue News (2026). Flávio Bolsonaro’s Party acknowledges Lula’s victory with reservations —Trump expresses doubts. blue News. [online] 27 Oct. Available at:


Newsroom 11/09/2026 12:05 (n.d.). Gilmar Mendes proposes 18 month transition to lei da ficha limpa rules. [online] Jurinews. Available at: https://jurinews.com.br/index.php/en/destaque-nacional/gilmar-mendes-proposes-18-month-transition-to-lei-da-ficha-limpa-rules-33173 [Accessed 2 Nov. 2026]


Lula’s Electoral Win and Bolsonaro’s Departure Deepen Tensions Between Brazil and


LatinNews. (2010). Brazil: Supreme court targets politicians. [online] Available at:


The Rio Times (2026). Brazil’s ficha limpa law awaits Supreme Court ruling weeks before vote. [online] The Rio Times. Available at: https://www.riotimesonline.com/brazil-ficha-limpa-supreme-court-ruling-2026/ [Accessed 1 Nov. 2026].


Grainger, J. (n.d.). Flávio Bolsonaro says he will request ‘annulment’ of election. [online] Batimes.com.ar. Available at: https://batimes.com.ar/news/latin-america/flavio-bolsonaro-refuses-to-recognise-lula-win-in-brazil-will-request-annulment-of-election.phtml [Accessed 1 Nov. 2026].


Lula wins re-election as Bolsonaro rejects result. (2026). The New York Times. [online] 25 Oct. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/live/2026/10/25/world/brazil-election [Accessed 3 Nov. 2026].


Rosenn, K. (2011). Procedural Protection of Constitutional Rights in Brazil. American Journal of Comparative Law, 59(4), pp.1009–1050. doi:10.5131/ajcl.2010.0033.

 

 
 
 

Comments


© 2025 by UCL LAW FOR ALL SOCIETY 

bottom of page